What is participatory science?
Participatory sciences come in many forms. The wide diversity of disciplines, subjects, players, methods and aims calls for a broad definition: " participatory sciences are defined as forms of scientific knowledge production in which non-scientific-professional players, whether individuals or groups, participate actively and deliberately ".
Référence :
The rise of participatory science
The last ten years have seen a boom in participatory science. Driven by a growing demand for knowledge about the state of biodiversity, this craze for participatory science owes much to a new generation of digital tools (mobile applications and portals) that are transforming wildlife observation practices for the general public and professionals alike.
In the majority of participatory science programs, a step-by-step application guides data collection (counts, photographs, measurements), helps with identification, locates and directly collects data for researchers to access. These micro-tasks are accessible to as many people as possible, and the data is made valid thanks to the compilation of a very large number of observations.
In the English-speaking world, the natural sciences have long been open to "participatory science" approaches. In France, it was in the 1980s that participatory science programs first saw the light of day, such as the STOC program (which enables volunteer ornithologists to take part in standardized monitoring of breeding populations of common birds) or the Vigie-Natureprogram, run by the Muséum national d'Histoire naturelle.
In 2021, 121,471 citizens contributed to a participatory biodiversity science program in France.
The Stratégie nationale de Biodiversité 2011-2020 has made citizen mobilization and initiative a strategic objective. The French Biodiversity Office (OFB), which has become the armed wing of these policies, even includes the number of participants in these observation programs among its ecological transition indicators.
In addition to the natural sciences, there are numerous initiatives in disciplines as diverse as archaeology, astronomy and epidemiology.
Références :
In 2021, 121,471 citizens contributed to a participatory biodiversity science program in France
The indicator produced each year by the Collectif national sciences participatives biodiversité presents the number of active participants in participatory science programs (who have provided at least one datum) during the year, providing a (non-exhaustive) idea of citizen activity around biodiversity-related participatory science programs.
Participation in 2021 is down slightly on 2020 (140,000), the year of confinement which saw a very sharp increase in the number of observers. During containment, for example, 22,000 people took part in the observation of over one and a half million birds.
Référence :
Plurality of forms and figures of commitment in participatory science
In a study devoted to citizen participation in participatory science, Florence Millerand, professor-researcher at the Université du Québec à Montréal (UQAM), observes a "plurality of forms and figures of commitment". "A first approach to these figures of engagement consists in identifying those present in the discourses and denominations used to qualify the actors: non-professionals, non-scientists, laymen, general public, citizens, volunteers, amateurs, etc. (...) To each of these figures corresponds an ethos understood in the sense of a way of thinking about the relations between science and society, here mainly from the point of view of the scientific sphere". She thus distinguishes six figures:
- Volunteers " whose commitment is based on giving. The commitment aims, through the act of contribution, to give (or give back) to a project, an institution, including science, or to society more generally".
- The enthusiast " who is distinguished by an often profound attachment, either to the object at the heart of his involvement, be it plants or stem cells, or to the activity or task itself".
- The " conscientious " who, unlike the volunteer, is motivated by the social or political cause to which his or her commitment contributes, such as biodiversity or the fight against cancer. Commitment is directly linked to the expression of a conscience and its implementation.
- Thescience enthusiast, "whose commitment is driven by the production of knowledge. This figure, which corresponds to the emblematic, sometimes fantasized, figure of the participant in participatory science projects (embodied in the expression "citizen scientist"), refers to a person driven essentially by the desire to participate in the development of scientific knowledge".
- Theenthusiast of the device, "attached above all to the socio-technical device, which can refer to both a technical dimension (the handling of equipment) and a human dimension (the collective of people involved)".
- Theexpert or professional amateur, "whose commitment is based on expertise and its recognition (...) Unlike the science amateur, whose identity as a 'knower' is defined directly in relation to a scientific field, the recognition of expertise is directed here towards the construction of one's personal identity as an expert".
"These multiple figures highlight important differences in the forms of expertise and the way they are distributed between players. In fact, these figures reflect particular relationships to knowledge, in which different visions of the relationship between science and society are expressed".
Référence :
Mosaic, a participatory science competence center
The Museum of Natural History and Sorbonne University have combined their expertise in a scientific unit, Mosaic ("Methods and tools for participatory science"), to support researchers from incubation to delivery of a participatory digital platform. Mosaic is made up of a team of experts: researchers, IT developers and participatory science experts.
Référence :
An online tool for training in Participatory Science
The Museum national d'Histoire naturelle, the UMS Mosaïc and the Union nationale des Centres permanents d'initiatives pour l'environnement (CPIE) have designed an online tool for training in the skills needed to run participatory science programs, organized around six modules:
- Understanding the landscape of participatory science in biodiversity
- Create your own participatory biodiversity science program
- Manage your participatory biodiversity science program
- Gather data and make it usable and useful
- Evaluate your program
- Sustain your program with an adapted socio-economic model
Référence :
Participatory epidemiology: when the public takes part in monitoring and understanding Covid-19
"From March-April 2020, faced with the limitations of the data collected by emergency services and hospitals, the idea of relying on the public to complete knowledge of the epidemic took hold. In just a few weeks, a flurry of online questionnaires and surveys was launched to identify symptoms and enrich the clinical picture, count cases, map the spread, and understand transmission mechanisms". In a dossier devoted to the various forms of public participation in epidemiological surveys, Maurice Ronai and Sophie Pène look back at several significant achievements.
In the UK, the Covid Symptom Study mobile app offered volunteers daily questionnaires inviting them to describe their state of health. At the end of March 2020, daily health data from 2,400,000 respondents showed that, among frequent symptoms (aches and pains, chills, fatigue, headaches and diarrhea, loss of sense of smell and taste), the latter symptom was three times higher among those testing positive. Researchers can therefore identify the loss of smell and taste as a very good predictor of infection. Downloaded by four million people, with up to 850,000 daily contributors, recording over 480 million health reports, Covid Symptom Study has resulted in 50 scientific articles in peer-reviewed journals.
In the United States, the Covid Near You project enabled over 444,000 people in the USA to report their symptoms in March 2020. Reporting was fast, simple and anonymous, with a simple introductory question: "How are you feeling?" By August 2020, the platform had collected over a million reports, providing information on Covid symptomatology and key demographic risk factors).
Référence :
Rencontres nationales "Sciences Participatives" on October 12-13, 2023 in Marseille, France
Organized jointly for the first time by the Collectif national Sciences participatives - Biodiversité and the Collectif Vigie Mer, the Rencontres nationales Sciences Participatives will revolve around a cross-cutting theme: "How can we improve the link between research, civil society and citizens through participatory sciences for the ecological transition and the sea of tomorrow?"
The first day will be devoted to exploratory workshops, testimonials, feedback and co-construction, and the second to an open forum.
These sharing days are aimed at professionals involved in participatory science: those involved in maritime life, biodiversity, scientists, managers, program leaders, educators, teachers, etc.
Référence :
Sources
3. Participatory science revolutionizes biodiversity monitoring
4. Evolution of citizen involvement in biodiversity-related participatory sciences
5. Citizen participation in participatory science: forms and figures of commitment
8. Participatory epidemiology: when the public takes part in monitoring and understanding Covid-19
9. Rencontres nationales Sciences Participatives on October 12-13, 2023, in Marseille